Showing posts with label RPT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RPT. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 13, 2019

GenM: RPT Gone Bad!

After the market close on 7 August, GenM announced that it would acquire a 46%-stake in Nasdaq-listed Empire Resorts Inc from its major shareholder at USD128.6 million (or at a price of USD9.74 apiece) (here). 

On 8 August, GenM share price dropped sharply due to concern about this related party transaction. On 9 August, investors began buying into the stock on the hope that GenM would recover after a few quarters down the road.

Yesterday, Empire Resorts share price plunged 12% to close at USD8.18 on news that the company has highlighted to its shareholders that it is contemplating the option of filing for voluntary bankruptcy during the announcement of its result to enable it to easier restructure its borrowings (here). 

To be fair, bankruptcy filings may be a tactical move which savvy investors and companies would employ in order to regulate their affair. However, normal investors are put off by this move which suggests the company's financial condition is quite bad. Even for a well-read person like myself, the move by the major shareholder to tap his listed vehicle for fund to finance its loss-making company in New York is not appropriate. What makes this transaction even worse are:
1. the announcement was not made with full candor regarding the state of financial condition of Empire Resorts; 
2. the shareholders do not have an option to vote on the acquisition as the purchase consideration is below the 5% asset value threshold; and 
3. the purchase price is now higher than the current market price.
As this seemingly unfair transaction will likely affect market perception about the Genting group, I expect the share prices of the group's listed vehicles will trade at a discount for a while until investors have forgotten about their bad experience. For now, I think it is best to avoid this group unless the share prices have dropped significantly enough as to warrant a trading BUY.


Chart 1: Genm's monthly chart as at Aug 13, 2018_12.30 (Source: Malaysiastock.com)


Chart 2: Genting's monthly chart as at Aug 13, 2018_12.30 (Source: Malaysiastock.com)

Wednesday, August 07, 2019

GENM: Not Another RPT!

GenM announced its acquisition of a 35%-stake in the US-listed Empire Resorts (Code: NYNY) for USD128.6 million. GenM is acquiring the stake from Kien Huat Realty, the main shareholder of GenM's parent company, Genting. Thus, this acquisition will be a related party transaction ("RPT").

Generally speaking investors do not take well to any RPT. What make it even worse is this RPT involved GenM and Genting, which have a history of questionable RPTs. To add another level of suspicion, NYNY is in a loss-making company. How far would the share prices drop? 

If not for the recent good news regarding the resolution of the theme park issue at Resort World in Genting Highland, this negative news could well send the share prices of GenM and Genting to a new low for 2019. However, if we balance out the positive news with the negative RPT news, I think the share prices would be backstopped by the intermediate uptrend line, SS or the low recorded in May this year. Worse comes to worst, the low of December 2018 should be a strong support for both stocks.

Chart 1: GenM's daily chart as at Aug 7, 2019_10.40 (Source: Malaysiastock.biz)

Chart 2: Genting's daily chart as at Aug 7, 2019_10.40 (Source: Malaysiastock.biz)

Chart 3: NYNY's weekly chart as at Aug 6, 2019 (Source: Yahoo Finance)